An
Ancient Scottish Ballad
Introduction by Loretta Lynn Layman
This ancient, popular
Scottish ballad, first preserved in print by Thomas Percy in 1765 and
reprinted many times thereafter, has often been associated with the Lords of
Lynn in Ayrshire but in fact relates to the Lords of Lyne in Peeblesshire.The book in which Percy
published the ballad was devoted chiefly to English poetry, and he there
described this ballad as being ??originally composed beyond the Tweed?; i.e., in Scotland.The Lords of Lyne in
Peeblesshire lived in the Borders of Scotland by 1200 and perhaps as early as
1165.1/However, they became titularly
extinct by 1270,2/ while the Lynns of Ayrshire retained their title until at
least 1452 and a portion of their property until at least 1642.About 1600, Timothy Pont erred,
asserting that the ballad must have been a tale of the Lynns of Ayrshire
because, as he wrongly believed and stated, ??no other race of the same name and
designation [was] ever known to have existed in the country ...?3/ To his credit, however,
Pont, being primarily a cartographer and not an historian, admitted that local
[Ayrshire] tradition was silent on the subject.Again, as the record shows, there actually were others of the name, with
title, living in the Borders.Likely, it
was the early obscurity of the Lords of Lyne in Peeblesshire that led to Pont??s
false assumption and the propogation thereof by those who followed him.
Consider also the
secondary character in this ballad - John o?? the Scales.It can hardly be coincidence that he bears
the same unusual name as a certain land in Annandale, which also lies in the
Borders and, in fact, in close proximity to lands owned by the Lords of Lyne in
Peeblesshire.As evidenced in
manuscripts deposited with the National Archives of Scotland, ??the £5 lands of
Scales, lying in Annandale? was owned by ??John Irving, son of the late John
Irving of Scales? at least as early as 1526.4/While the place name Scales is not easily found, it survives as the
Annandale gorge called Scales Cleuch and is but a few miles from Scroggs and
Lyne, both once owned by the Lords of Lyne of Peeblesshire.John Irving of Scales, or some predecessor,
must be the person portrayed as John o?? the Scales in the
ancient ballad.
These facts point to one
of the Lords of Lyne in Peeblesshire, rather than the Lords of Lynn in
Ayrshire, as being the Heir of Linne in this ballad.With the honesty of Pont, however, it must be
told that, beginning in the twelfth century, the Lords of Lyne were no longer
Lynes but Hays.The Lords of Lynn in
Ayrshire, on the other hand, bore the name Lynn for several centuries
longer.The ballad takes
fifty-three verses for the telling.It
speaks of a young lord who squandered his inheritance but was given an
opportunity to regain it through the provision of his deceased father, who??d
had not only an understanding of the weakness of human nature but also an
appreciation of irony and the element of surprise. The words of the ballad
as published in 18455/, chosen over the 1765 version because it purports to
have had some language restored from the folio manuscript, are these:
_________________________________________
1/Caledonia: Or, an Historical and Topographical Account of North Britain, from the Most Ancient to the Present Times, New
Edition, Vol. II, George Chalmers, London (1887), pp. 539-40
2/The Book of StoboChurch. Being the First Volume of a Series of ??Books of the
Church,? compiled from original
sources by Dr. Gunn, Peebles (1907), p. 6
3/Topographical Account of the District of Cunningham,
Ayrshire. Compiled About the Year 1600 by Mr. Timothy Pont,
The Maitland Club, Glasgow (1858), p. 156