Chat's and Book Reviews
by Frank R. Shaw FSA Scot A History of Clan
Alastair Campbell of Airds, Her
Majestys Unicorn Pursuivant of Arms at the Court of the Lord Lyon, is
gifted as a writer and eminently qualified to put pen to paper regarding
the Campbells tribal history which has often been misunderstood, if not
wrongly misinterpreted. While Clan Campbell, like all clans, has committed
its share of questionable actions, Alastair Campbell has attempted to set
the record straight about the Campbells or, as Ernest Hemmingway often
said as a young man, "the true gen" or the real story.
Not many people have the privilege
of working directly for their Chief (some are more successful than
others), but Mr. Campbell was employed by the Duke of Argyll to be Chief
Executive of the Clan (yes, these are modern times!) and was in charge of
the Campbell archives for over a dozen years. As author of many books and
articles through the years, Alastair Campbell has put forth the first of
three volumes on the Clan Campbell. Volume 1 takes us
"From Origins to Flodden".
The other two, "From Flodden to the
Glorious Revolution" and
"From 1688 to the Present",
will appear in 2002 and 2004, respectively.
His Chief, the Duke of Argyll, who
recently passed away, says of the author, "From his first few decades he
kept meticulous notebooks, for no particular purpose other than his own
pleasure, and these were to prove invaluable in this work of heroic
Several things need
to be said about Volume 1 it is the story of a clan in search of itself,
the acquisition of land, power and prestige while, at the same time, it
tells of Clan Donalds loss of land, power and prestige over the years.
Naturally, the emphasis is on Clan Campbell, but of necessity, the book is
(to borrow Nigel Tranters title) "The Story of Scotland," albeit from the
perspective of Clan Campbell. It is the story of a clan that was good at
acquiring lands, holding on to them regardless, marrying well, fighting
even better, being on the right side most of the time, as well as being
very lucky. The "remarkable success" of Clan Campbell was not achieved
without major discomfort to their neighbors and envy among those less
successful. The author acknowledges they were good and lucky!
I started out thinking this might be
just another book of dull, boring "begats" and maybe a bit self serving.
But I quickly found out that the author has a winsome way with words, was
warned constantly not to write a partisan history, uses modern
illustrations to make his subject more appealing, gives a picture of Clan
Campbell that is frank, to the point or, as the author himself says, one
of "warts and all," and is interlaced with bits of humor.
Alastair Campbell is just as blunt
as he is humorous when it comes to what septs should not be in Clan
Campbell. Pity the poor Macelvies when Campbell says, "I can discern no
reason for the inclusion of this name among the septs of Clan Campbell,"
or "Once again, the reason for attributing membership of all those of the
name Hastings to Clan Campbell seem remarkably tenuous". Do not wear a red
tartan as some Campbells have because the author says there was never
"ever such a thing as the Red Campbell Tartan" period! It is a myth!
About pedigree, he bluntly states: "It need hardly be said that the
earliest generations of the pedigree are purely mythical and not to be
taken seriously, tempting as this is to the over-enthusiastic
His description of the lands and
isles in "Setting the Scene" transports one instantly to those wonderful
memories of previous trips to Argyll. The kinship to Robert the Bruce is
mentioned for the record but not dwelt upon. "Triumph and Disaster" is the
rise of the Campbells and the fall of the MacDonalds. He does not rub it
in writing about the MacDonalds. "The Clan: An Overall Survey" takes the
wind out of the sails of those who strut too much at Scottish games. The
"Broken Men" from "Broken Clans" is a fresh perspective on those of us who
fit that category. "Chieftains" are not to be found in Clan Campbell and
are not recognized by their Chief. If he did, he would have over 200 in
his clan who meet the Lord Lyons requirements. I love the story of the
artist who arrived to remove lines on the face of an Argyll portrait only
to discover it was an offending line in the tartan that was to be removed!
He packed his bags and left!
Every serious student of Scotland,
not just members of Clan Campbell, needs this book, as well as the next
two volumes. I paid $60 for my copy, and Ill gladly do the same for
volumes two and three. It is that good! There will be things you disagree
with Alastair Campbell about, but you cannot disagree that this is a book
worthy of any Highlanders library. This book is copyrighted by The Clan
Campbell Education Association and was published by Polygon at Edinburgh.
It is an imprint of Edinburgh University Press Ltd., 22 George Square,
Edinburgh EH8 9LF. A History of ClanCampbell, Volume 1, can
be found at Ward Weems and Sons, who advertise regularly in The Family
Tree, as well as at other fine book dealers.
Any author who wishes for their
latest book to be considered for review in this column is asked to send a
copy to me at 1320 Twelve Oaks Circle, NW, Atlanta, GA 30327-1862, USA.
Whether selected to be reviewed or not, the books become the property of
The Ellen Payne Odom Genealogy Library in Moultrie, GA.
This comment system requires
you to be logged in through either a Disqus account or an
account you already have with Google, Twitter, Facebook or
Yahoo. In the event you don't have an account with any of these
companies then you can create an account with Disqus. All
comments are moderated so they won't display until the moderator
has approved your comment.