Working Life of Linda Fabiani MSP
W/E 30th January 2005
commencing Monday 24th January 2005
trying hard to keep to my daily diary pledge, so it’s Monday night and
I’m reflecting over a really interesting day.
in East Kilbride in the morning at the opening of the new offices for
the Department for International Development – it’s great to think of
all these Lanarkshire folk beavering away in East Kilbride dealing with
issues all over the globe.
Benn, Secretary of State for International Development was there to
perform the plaque unveiling, and Adam Ingram, local Member of
Parliament and Defence Minister was one of the speakers. Adam spoke of
the way that the military function compliments international development
– peacekeeping, conflict resolution, upholding democracy, rebuilding
communities etc., but I couldn’t help but reflect that these platitudes
are easy to listen and nod to whilst you’re munching a buffet
chicken-tikka stick in a comfortable office in a business park in
Scotland: how would such sentiments be received currently in Iraq, for
example, and what about the anomaly of countries like the UK espousing
peace and democracy whilst selling millions and millions of pounds worth
of fighter jets, bombs, rifles, water cannon and batons etc. worldwide,
sometimes to dodgy regimes?
opening, myself and Des McNulty from the Labour Group in Holyrood had a
meeting with Mr. Benn. Des is Convener and I’m Vice Convener of the
Parliament’s International Development Group.
impressed whenever I’ve listened to Hillary Benn. I think he truly cares
about his job and also is very amenable to co-operating and sharing
information. He had arranged this meeting to discuss with the
Cross-party International Development Groups in our Parliament, and in
the Welsh and Irish Assemblies, how we could best work together. This
cross border co-operation is welcome – too often when I try to get
information about a matter ‘reserved’ to Westminster I am given short
shrift (the Home Office for example has a fortress mentality in regard
to refugee and asylum issues – maybe because they can’t justify their
position), and I was glad to hear Mr. Benn’s intention to maintain
communication and arrange further meetings. It was good too to meet
counterparts from Wales and Ireland and I really do hope that the Irish
Assembly will reconvene before too much longer.
through to the Edinburgh office and arrived here around 5.30 pm, just in
time for the event to launch Luath Press’s latest book “Agenda for a New
has been compiled, and is introduced by, my colleague Kenny MacAskill
and comprises essays from contributors about their vision of Scotland in
the year 2020. Lots of interesting contributions from people in all
different walks of life – academics, politicians, business people,
representatives of the arts and tourism. Kenny had asked me to
contribute a chapter and whilst it’s been an interesting experience, I
must admit to great stress and trepidation about writing something which
would then be published in A REAL BOOK! So, it’s done, it’s published
and I must admit to a bit of a thrill seeing my name on the front cover.
The only other time I have had anything published was in Peru, and that
was aimed at a particular audience rather than for general sale.
about “Scotland: Organising for Peace”, my view that in a world where
conflicts are increasing, there must be alternatives to the military
solution. I believe that Scotland is a nation well-placed to contribute
to good relations in the world and that we should both actively
recognise that and advance our case. I’m not going to say much more here
about that – it’s all in the book!
So, I’m off
home now, clutching my book and looking forward to reading the other
morning and the Standards Committee – generally housekeeping type
issues, so nothing much to report here. It’s now around 7.30 pm and I’ve
just returned from our Group Meeting, and clearing through the emails.
Reflecting on the day though, it’s very much been about culture and
arts. It’s Burns Day and following on from the debate about Burns in the
Parliament last week, the Living Tradition office in Kilmarnock visited
us here today, along with Robert Burns! Here’s Robert and I chewing the
felt strange sitting chatting here – started to feel real! I wonder what
Mr. Burns would have to say about Scotland today.
after my meeting with our national bard, I met with a representative of
the Faculty of Advocates who are sponsoring an exhibition about the
experiences of Refugees in Scotland, and wish to exhibit in Parliament.
I think we can facilitate this along with one of our meetings of the
Cross-Party Group on Refugees and Asylum Seekers and I’m looking forward
to seeing the exhibition. I was invited to the showing in Glasgow some
months ago, but wasn’t able to get along. It was an interesting meeting
and I was really interested in learning about some of the work that the
Faculty supports. While I was in Tanzania I met a group of women lawyers
who worked voluntarily to provide legal support to those who could not
afford it – I’m now wondering whether there are potential links with
women lawyers and advocates with which the Faculty here could assist.
Note in big red book – investigate!
from there for more art talk – quick meeting of the Art Group which has
been set up to oversee Art in the Parliament building. We have not
really taken off yet, but things are moving now because potential
Curators are being interviewed next week. It will be good to get someone
in-house who really knows what they are about – many colleagues approach
me with suggestions for art, there have been lots of offers of artworks,
but everything is on hold until we have the Curator in post.
apologies – it’s 10 pm Thursday night and I’m looking back over
Wednesday and today. Wednesday was such a rush around day that I didn’t
have a minute to spare. It started with the Communities Committee in the
morning – still taking evidence on Charity Law Reform, but that’s the
evidence taking complete and we’re now scheduling additional meetings so
that we can compile our report on this issue whilst taking evidence on
the next one – the Housing Bill.
afternoon’s debate in the Chamber was about the contribution that older
people make to our society – another of these debates where there is a
lot of talk but not a lot of action. Sometimes I feel that the
Executive’s motions for debate are a bit self-congratulatory and then
they seem to take offence at the opposition not agreeing! There are
times for agreement of course, but Oppositions are there to hold
Governments to account, and where we feel that the rhetoric doesn’t
match the reality then that’s what we do.
contributed to this debate on behalf of elderly carers in general and a
particular aspect – elderly carers who are looking after adult children
with learning/intellectual difficulties. I’ve been lobbying about this
issue for almost two years now, to no avail. It seems so very
straightforward to me, but no-one who can do anything seems to be
listening. It first came to my notice in East Kilbride where a group of
such parents have come together. All they want is to see their child
settled before they are too ill to look after them, or indeed are no
longer there. Even though I’m representing this Group the local Council
refuses to meet with me to discuss it – their view is that they are
meeting Executive guidelines (tick box culture). The Group ended up
submitting a Public Petition and this is currently ongoing. I know I’ve
spoken about this in my diary before, I could talk about it at great
length and the struggle goes on. In the Chamber you’re only allowed
around 5 minutes though and what I said is reproduced below:
Linda Fabiani (Central Scotland) (SNP):
While Mr Sheridan was speaking, I was reflecting on the
irony of our having debated closing the opportunity gap last week when
we hear proof yet again that the gap between the rich and the poor is
widening all the time in this country.
Today's debate is about older people. I will focus on one
sector of the elderly population: elderly carers, who are mentioned in
the Scottish National Party amendment and who are referred to in some
measure in what the Executive's motion says about the contribution that
older people make to our communities. I can think of no bigger
contribution than that which is made by elderly carers. In Scotland,
500,000 people are carers and most of them are over 55 years old. Those
figures come directly from the Scottish Executive's website.
A couple of years ago, Help the Aged commissioned a
study, which was carried out by the University of Kent, called "Caring
in Later Life: Reviewing the role of older carers". It painted a bleak
United Kingdom-wide picture and, despite there having been enacted under
devolution some legislation that affects carers, all would agree that we
still have a long way to go. That study found that more than half of
older carers suffer from a long-standing illness or disability. It
revealed that three quarters of the older people who live with the
person for whom they care receive no regular visits from the health
service, social services or home-care agencies and that more than half
of them put in long hours of intensive caring on very low incomes while
suffering from serious health problems. One third of those carers said
that they had never had a break, and carers aged 75 or over were more
likely to provide intensive care than those between 60 and 74.
That brings me to another UK study, which was carried out
by Jane Hubert and Sheila Hollins, about people with intellectual
disabilities and their elderly carers. I will focus on that topic,
because I have met many people in my region who are in that situation.
The majority of people with intellectual disabilities—or learning
disabilities, as they are also called—in the UK live at home with their
families, usually with their parents or, more commonly in later life,
with one parent, usually their mother. That raises many issues. For
parent and for adult son or daughter, there is a physical issue. When a
person is getting older, something as basic as mobility affects
significantly how well they can care for the person whom they love so
Mental health is also an issue:
"Psychiatric disorders, including depression, affective
disorders, anxiety disorders and delusional disorders, are more frequent
among elderly people with intellectual disabilities than among the
general elderly population."
I quote from the report that I mentioned, because the
researchers say it better than I can.
It is clear that aging carers and their adult children
will have a complex set of individual and joint needs. The needs of an
older person with intellectual disabilities may conflict badly with
those of an elderly parent. I have had the privilege of meeting the
Murray Owen Carers Group, which is a group of elderly carers of adult
children with learning disabilities in East Kilbride and I have heard
some of their stories of the very basic difficulties that they face. For
example—this is about a lady I know—how is a woman of 80 supposed to
cope with the fact that her son, who is over 40, refuses to get into the
bath or shower in the morning? That is very difficult, in both a
physical and a mental sense. The stress is enormous.
There are also worries about bereavement when it comes to
elderly parents. For people with learning disabilities, the loss of a
parent—especially the sole surviving parent—is so much worse than it is
for the average person, because they can find it so difficult to
understand that their mother is no longer there one day when they come
home from the learning centre. People in that situation can often be
excluded from the rituals and processes that are associated with illness
and death. Although they are aware that their life has suddenly changed,
they sometimes do not understand why. Couple that with their having to
move into a strange environment, which might be an institution or some
kind of accommodation that they share with other people or another
family. They might instead stay in the same house; I know someone in
that situation. A person can end up staying in the same place, with a
visit two or three times a day from a carer or from assorted carers.
Such a change in a person's life must be absolutely awful for them to
Planning must begin long before that point is reached. I
would like the Executive to consider that seriously. The Murray Owen
Carers Group has submitted a public petition, because it feels that
despite implementation of "The same as you?" whose good intentions the
group does not knock in any way, there are many hidden families whose
needs are not being addressed because everything is focused on taking
people from institutions—quite rightly—and putting them back into the
I ask the Minister for Communities or the Deputy Minister
for Communities to meet me and representatives of the Murray Owen Carers
Group. I am sure that the group represents people from all over the
country who are in the same position. Let us see whether we can make a
difference to the lives of people who contribute so much to our
communities here in Scotland.
I ended by
asking the Minister to meet with the Murray Owen Group, and intervened
on him later to repeat the request – declined. So, we’re hoping the
Public Petitions Committee will recognise the problem.
of ‘housing’, firstly meeting with housing professionals and then a
meeting of the Cross-Party Group on Affordable Housing. The topic for
discussion this evening was stopping the Right to Buy – whilst this
measure would not instantly solve the housing crisis, it would help in
the longer term.
reason I didn’t do my diary last night was that I dashed off to dinner
with two dear friends, one of whom is moving from Edinburgh to
Yorkshire. I’ll miss him, but I guess it’s another place to visit!
time – I slept in this morning, Thursday. Nothing to do with
over-indulging at dinner I hasten to add – I set my phone alarm for 8 pm
instead of 8 am! I wakened up with a jolt at 10.30, realised that I was
missing Chamber, but thankfully I wasn’t down to speak in the Energy
Debate. I got there in time for First Minister’s Questions, so managed
to avoid the wrath of Tricia the Whip. Tricia allowed me off this
afternoon, because the National Holocaust Memorial Day Ceremony was
being held in Hamilton. So a couple of hours with David about local
casework and then to the Town House.
arrived home from Hamilton, and I can’t begin to tell you how impressed
I am with how South Lanarkshire Council organised today’s events, and
this evening’s ceremony. It was performed by primary school children,
secondary school children and the local youth drama group. From the
initial exhibition in the hall, right through to the last piece of music
in the ceremony, it was moving, compassionate, thoughtful, and yet
serious in its intent to portray both the horror of the time and the
necessity for recognising that such things still go on – Rwanda where 1m
died, East Timor where one-third of the population was wiped out,
Cambodia under Khmer Rouge, Bosnia.
Minister had announced earlier in the day that it was the intention that
school pupils learn about the Holocaust, with teaching packs being sent
out to all schools. This is welcome, because it is true that if you
don’t acknowledge history then you’re in danger of repeating it, and the
younger people are in such recognition and learning the better.
lunchtime and I’m about to set off for the Staff Christmas Lunch – yes,
I did say Christmas Lunch; this is the earliest we were able to get us
all together! This morning I had a look over some of the things David
had updated me on the day before in Lanarkshire.
on occasion a constituency case with extremely distressing circumstances
that you feel almost powerless to do anything about. Often it’s about
relationship breakdown and the associated conflict – verbal and physical
threats, abusive phone calls, the targeting of extended family members
who have little or nothing at all to do with the whole debacle. These
situations are so much worse if children are involved and often parents
are so caught up in their own turmoil that the needs of the child are
ignored. It’s stating the obvious to say that the emotional upheaval can
have a very dramatic impact on the lives of the people involved and
there are no simple words or actions that can make these stressful
circumstances simply go away.
with cases like these, Davie and I often feel that any advice we can
give is inadequate and that we’re just not able to do anything except
give encouragement to go the police, solicitor, social work, self-help
group, mediation service, anything that might help. But seeking help is
itself no easy thing for people to do and may initially even add to the
intense sense of anxiety. It can sometimes though be a catalyst for both
sides to accept that something is finally over and agree to move on with
slightly lighter note, although by no means less important if you are
directly affected, I have a constituency case this week that arises
every now and then. Namely the lack of disabled car parking spaces and
the attendant problem of unregistered drivers using them and blocking
the ‘blue badge’ holders. I have heard unregistered drivers at times
openly admit to using disabled spaces, feeling no remorse at all because
they believe that most of the badge-holders are not genuine. Well, let
me tell you, as a representative on a couple of occasions of someone
trying to qualify for a ‘blue badge’, it’s not always easy!
Now we have
all heard the stories about how some people with registered disabilities
have “nothing wrong with them”, how we see them get “in and out of their
cars with no problems”, but not all disabilities are immediately
apparent. Sometimes folk equate disability only with wheelchairs or
walking sticks, or with guide dogs or hearing aids. Most of us though
will have known someone in our lives who look physically okay but have
difficulties with walking or breathing, someone who perhaps has had to
take a load of medication just to get out the front door. Sometimes
these are the people who need to park close to where they’re headed. If
I ever have the misfortune to suffer from debilitating ill health, I
hope that the small allowance of a car parking space is not considered
too much to ask.
Saturday morning, and unusually I’m in the Edinburgh office today – I
had to come through to Edinburgh to host a dinner last night: If a group
want to hold a function in the Parliament Restaurant the event has to be
sponsored by an MSP. So last night I sponsored the RMJM dinner. RMJM is
the architectural practise which partnered the Catalonian firm, EMBT
(Miralles) in designing the Holyrood Parliament complex. The boss wanted
to hold a dinner in the Parliament for all of his staff, past and
current, who had worked on the project design. So, 95 guests! It was a
really enjoyable evening – all were clearly delighted to be seated in
the completed building eating dinner, and the Restaurant did a grand job
– food and service were excellent.
Holyrood Project design was of course extremely complex and very much in
the public eye in terms of the chamber, the MSP block, the garden lobby
etc. It was good to see the recognition being given to the work of the
architects, engineers, technicians and back-up staff who had
concentrated on some of the very necessary but unexciting parts of the
overall design – the basement, the plumbing, materials’ components –
metre upon metre of stainless steel, acres of concrete, wood, glass –
service hatches, the list goes on and on. Whatever anyone thinks about
the architects or the builders, about the civil service or the
politicians, whatever anyone thinks about the design and finish of the
Holyrood complex and its cost, there were people who worked extremely
hard to make it all come together, and who no-one ever saw. I reckon
they deserved it their dinner last night.
signing off now and posting my diary to Electric Scotland straight away,
because Monday and Tuesday I’m off to Dumfries & Galloway for various
meetings and fact-finding visits about housing and the voluntary sector.
I need all of tomorrow for the preparation. Until next week … … …
This comment system requires
you to be logged in through either a Disqus account or an
account you already have with Google, Twitter, Facebook or
Yahoo. In the event you don't have an account with any of these
companies then you can create an account with Disqus. All
comments are moderated so they won't display until the moderator
has approved your comment.