ERSKINE, REV. DR. JOHN, was
born on the 2nd of June, 1721. He was the eldest son of John Erskine of
Carnock, the celebrated author of the Institutes of the Law of Scotland, a
younger branch of the noble family of Buchan. His mother was Margaret,
daughter of the honourable James Melville of Bargarvie, of the family of
Leven and Melville. Young Erskine was taught the elementary branches of his
education by private tuition, and was placed, towards the close of the year
1734, at the university of Edinburgh, where he acquired a great fund of
classical knowledge, and made himself master of the principles of philosophy
and law. He was originally intended for the profession of the law, in which
his father had been so much distinguished; but a natural meditative and
religious disposition inclined him towards the church. This peculiar turn of
mind had displayed itself at a very early age, when, instead of joining in
the games and amusements suitable to the period of boyhood, he was retired
and solitary, and preferred the more exalted pleasures of religious
meditation; so that while his companions were pursuing their youthful
sports, he would be found shut up in his closet, employed in the study of
the scriptures, and in exercises of devotion. Although his taste thus led
him towards the sacred profession, yet in compliance with the wishes of his
parents, he repressed his own inclinations, and passed through the greater
part of that course of discipline prescribed in Scotland, in former times,
as preparatory to entering the faculty of advocates. But at length, deeply
impressed with the conviction that it was his duty to devote himself to the
service of religion, he communicated to his father his intention to study
divinity. This resolution met with the decided opposition of his family.
They conceived that the clerical office was at best but ill suited for the
display of those talents which they knew him to possess, while the very
moderate provision made for the clergy of the church of Scotland, has always
been a prudential obstacle with the parents and guardians of young men of
family or consideration in this country. In spite, however, of every
opposition, Erskine persevered in the prosecution of his theological
studies, and on their completion, in the year 1743, he was licensed to
preach, by the presbytery of Dumblane.
Prior to the commencement of Dr
Erskine’s classical education, an ardent desire to cultivate literature and
philosophy had manifested itself in Scotland, and the professors of the college
of Edinburgh, some of them men of the most distinguished talents, had
contributed greatly to promote and cherish the spirit which animated the nation.
Among those early benefactors of Scottish literature, the most conspicuous were
Sir John Pringle, and Mr Stevenson, professors of moral philosophy and of logic,
in the university of Edinburgh. One mode which these eminent men adopted in
order to stimulate the exertions of their students, was to prescribe topics
connected with the subject of their respective prelections, on which their
pupils were required to write short dissertations; when these exercises were to
be read, numbers attended from the different classes, and we are informed by Dr
Erskine, that Dr William Wishart, principal of the college, "that great
encourager of the study of the classics, and of moral and political sciences,
would often honour those discourses with his presence, listen to them with
attention, criticise them with candour; and when he observed indications of good
dispositions, and discerned the blossoms of genius, on these occasions, and
afterwards, as he had opportunity, testified his esteem and regard." Professor
Stevenson selected a number of the best of the essays which were read in his
class, and bound them up in a volume, which is now preserved in the college
library. They are in the hand-writing of their authors; and in this curious
repository are to be found the productions of Erskine and Robertson, together
with those of many young men who afterwards rose to eminence in their several
paths of life. We have Dr Erskine’s authority for saying, that during the time
he was at the university, "Edinburgh college then abounded with young men of
conspicuous talents, and indefatigable application to study; many of whom
afterwards rose to high eminence in the state, in the army, and in the learned
professions, especially in the law department." Amongst these we may name as his
intimate friends, Sir Thomas Miller of Glenlee, afterwards lord president of the
court of session, and those distinguished lawyers who were promoted to the bench
under the titles of lords Elliock, Alva, Kennet, Gardenston, and Braxfield.
In May, 1744, Dr Erskine was
ordained minister of Kirkintilloch, in the presbytery of Glasgow, where he
remained until the year 1753, when he was presented to the parish of Culross, in
the presbytery of Dunfermline. In June, 1758, he was translated to the new Grey
Friars, one of the churches of Edinburgh. In November, 1766, the university of
Glasgow conferred on him the honorary degree of doctor of divinity, and in July,
1767, he was promoted to the collegiate charge of old Grey Friars, where he had
for his colleague Dr Robertson.
In the different parishes in
which Dr Erskine had ministered, he had enjoyed the esteem and affection of his
parishioners. They were proud of him for his piety, learning, and rank;—they
were delighted and improved by his public and private instructions, and they
deeply lamented his removal when called from them to undertake the more
important charges to which his merit successively promoted him. His attention to
the duties of the pastoral office was most exemplary, and his benevolent
consolation and advice, which were at the service of all who required them,
secured him the respect and affection of his flock, who long remembered him with
feelings of the warmest gratitude. No man ever had a keener relish for the
pleasures of conversation; but in these he considered, that he ought not to
indulge, conceiving his time and talents to be entirely the property of his
parishioners. At college, he had made great attainments in classical learning,
and through life, he retained a fondness for the cultivation of literature and
philosophy, in which his great talents fitted him to excel; he refrained,
however, from their pursuit, restricting himself in a great measure, to the
discharge of his important religious duties. But although literature was not
allowed to engross a large share of his attention, nor to interfere with his
more sacred avocations, still, by much exertion, and by economizing his time, he
was enabled to maintain a perfect acquaintance with the progress of the arts and
Perhaps, no country in the world
ever made more rapid progress in literature than Scotland did during the last
half of the eighteenth century. And it is to Dr Erskine chiefly, that the nation
is indebted for that improvement which took place in our theological writings,
and in the manner in which the services of the pulpit were performed. Previous
to the time when he was licensed, sermons abounded with discursive and diffuse
illustrations, and were deformed by colloquial familiarities and vulgar
provincialisms; and although the discourses of such men as Robertson, Home, and
Logan, and others of their contemporaries, were conspicuous for their beauty,
still it is to the published sermons of Dr Erskine, that the perspicuity and
good taste subsequently displayed in the addresses from the pulpit have been
justly traced. Even before the publication of his sermons, however, Dr Erskine
had been favourably known to the public. His first publication was a pamphlet
against certain of the doctrines contained in Dr Campbell’s work, on the
"necessity of revelation." In this production, Erskine had occasion to advocate
some of the opinions maintained in Dr Warburton’s Divine Legation of Moses; and
having presented that distinguished prelate with a copy of the pamphlet, a
correspondence ensued, highly creditable to Erskine, from the terms in which
Warburton addresses him; more particularly when it is considered that at this
time Erskine had not attained his 21st year.
About the time when Dr Erskine
obtained his license, a remarkable concern for religion had been exhibited in
the British colonies of North America. In order to obtain the earliest and most
authentic religious intelligence from those provinces, he commenced a
correspondence with those chiefly concerned in bringing about this change; nor
was this correspondence confined to America. He also opened a communication with
several divines of the most distinguished piety on the continent of Europe. This
intercourse he assiduously cultivated and carried on during the whole of his
life. One bad consequence of it was the toil which it necessarily entailed on
him, not only in answering his numerous correspondents, but in being called upon
by the friends of deceased divines, to correct and superintend the publication
of posthumous works. To his voluntary labours in this way, the religious world
is indebted for the greater part of the works of president Edwards, and Dickson,
and of Stoddart, and Fraser of Alness. Such was Dr Erskine’s thirst for
information concerning the state of religion, morality, and learning on the
continent, that in his old age, he undertook and acquired a knowledge of the
Dutch and German languages. The fruits of the rich field which was thus thrown
open to him appeared in "The Sketches and Hints of Church History and
Theological Controversy, chiefly translated or abridged from modern Foreign
Writers. Edinburgh, vol. 1st, 1790, vol. 2nd, 1799." These volumes contained the
most extensive and interesting body of information respecting the state of
religion on the Continent, which had been presented to the world.
One of the objects professed by
the promoters of those revolutionary principles, which, towards the close of the
last century threatened the subversion of social order in Europe, was the
destruction of all christian church establishments; and an association was
actually formed on the continent for this purpose. Dr Erskine, however, having
in the course of his researches into the state of religion, discovered the
existence of this association, gave the alarm to his countrymen; and professor
Robinson and the Abbe Barruel soon after investigated its rise and progress, and
unfolded its dangers. The patriotic exertions of those good men were crowned
with success. Many of those who had been imposed upon by the specious arguments
then in vogue, were recalled to a sense of reason and duty; and even the
multitude were awakened to a sense of the impending danger, when the true
character of the religion and morality of those political regenerators, who
would have made them their dupes, were disclosed and illustrated by the
practical commentary which the state of France afforded. The consideration that
he had assisted to save this country from the horrors to which the French nation
had been subjected, was one of the many gratifying reflections which solaced Dr
Erskine on looking back, in his old age, on his laborious and well spent life.
Dr Erskine’s zeal in the cause of
religion led him to take a large share in the business of the society for the
propagation of christian knowledge; and even when, through the infirmities of
bad health and old age, he was unable to attend the meetings of that body, such
was the dependence of the directors on his information and sound judgment, that
on any difficulty occurring in the management of their affairs, they were in the
habit of consulting him at his own house. In the general assembly of the church
of Scotland, he was for many years the leader of the popular party; there the
openness and integrity of his character secured him the confidence and affection
of his friends and the esteem and respect of his opponents. The friendship which
subsisted between him and principal Robertson, the leader of the moderate party,
has been objected to by some of his more rigid admirers, as displaying too great
a degree of liberality—a fact strongly illustrative of the rancour which existed
in former times among the high church party. The courtesy which marked Dr
Erskine’s conduct to principal Robertson throughout their lives, and the candour
which led him to bear testimony to the high talents and many estimable qualities
of the historian, in the funeral sermon which he preached on the death of that
great man, did equal honour to Dr Erskine’s head and his heart. The following
anecdote has been told of one rupture of the friendship which subsisted in early
life between principal Robertson and Dr Erskine. Mr Whitefield, who was sent by
the English methodists as a missionary into Scotland, at first formed a
connection with the Seceders, the body which had left the established
church; but when he refused to confine his ministrations to them, they declared
enmity against him, and his character became a controversial topic. Mr Erskine,
some time before he obtained the living of Kirkintilloch, appears to have been a
great admirer of the character of this celebrated preacher, and to have been
strongly impressed with the force of his powerful eloquence and the usefulness
and efficacy of his evangelical doctrines. It unfortunately happened, that at
the time when the friends and enemies of Mr Whitefield were keenly engaged in
discussing his merits, the question as to his character and usefulness was made
the subject of debate in a literary society which Robertson and Erskine had
formed. Conflicting opinions were expressed, and the debate was conducted with
so much zeal and asperity that it occasioned not only the dissolution of the
society, but it is said to have led to a temporary interruption of the private
friendship and intercourse which subsisted between Erskine and Robertson. There
is another anecdote of these two great men, which tells more favourably for Dr
Erskine’s moderation and command of temper, and at the same time shows the
influence which he had acquired over the Edinburgh mob. During the disturbances
in Edinburgh in the years 1778 and 1779, occasioned by the celebrated bill,
proposed at that time to be introduced into parliament, for the repeal of the
penal statutes against the Roman catholics in Scotland, the populace of
Edinburgh assembled in the College court, with the intention of demolishing the
house of principal Robertson, who had taken an active part in advocating the
abolition of these penal laws; and there seems to be little doubt that the mob
would have attempted to carry their threats into execution in defiance of the
military, which had been called out, had not Dr Erskine appeared, and by his
presence and exhortations, dispersed them.
Dr Erskine’s opinions, both in
church and state politics, will be best understood from the following short
account of the part which he took on several of the important discussions which
divided the country during his life. In the year 1769, on the occasion of the
breach with America, he entered into a controversy with Mr Wesley, and published
more than one pamphlet, deprecating the contest. He was an enemy to the new
constitution given to Canada, by which he considered the catholic religion to be
too much favoured. In 1778, when the attempt was made to repeal certain of the
penal enactments against the Roman catholics of Great Britain, he testified his
apprehensions of the consequences in a correspondence between him and Mr Burke,
which was published. And finally, we have already seen, that he took an active
and prominent part, in his old age, in support of constitutional principles,
when threatened by the French revolution.
Having attained to the 82d year
of his age, Dr Erskine was suddenly struck with a mortal disease, and died at
his house in Lauriston Lane, Edinburgh, on the 19th of January, 1803, after a
few hours’ illness. He had been from his youth of a feeble constitution, and for
many years previous to his death, his appearance had been that of one in the
last stage of existence; and during many winters he had been unable to perform
his sacred duties with regularity; nor did he once preach during the last
sixteen months of his life. Before he was entirely incapacitated for public
duty, his voice had become too weak to be distinctly heard by his congregation.
Still, however, the vivacity of his look and the energy of his manner, bespoke
the warmth of his heart and the vigour of his mind. His mental faculties
remained unimpaired to the last; and, unaffected by his bodily decay, his memory
was as good, his judgment as sound, his imagination as lively, and his
inclination for study as strong, as during his most vigorous years, and to the
last he was actively engaged in those pursuits which had formed the business and
pleasure of his life. Even the week before his death, he had sent notice to his
publisher, that he had collected materials for, the 6th number of the periodical
pamphlet he was then publishing, entitled, "Religious intelligence from abroad."
In his temper, Dr Erskine was
ardent and benevolent, his affections were warm, his attachments lasting; and
his piety constant and most sincere. He was remarkable for the simplicity of his
manners, and for that genuine humility which is frequently the concomitant and
brightest ornament of high talents. In his beneficence, which was great but
unostentatious, he religiously observed the Scripture precept in the
distribution of his charity and in the performance of his many good and friendly
offices. We cannot close this short sketch of Dr Erskine more appropriately than
in the graphic words of our great novelist, who, in his Guy Mannering, has
presented us, as it were, with a living picture of this eminent divine. "The
colleague of Dr Robertson ascended the pulpit. His external appearance was not
prepossessing. A remarkably fair complexion, strangely contrasted with a black
wig, without a grain of powder; a narrow chest and a stooping posture; hands
which, placed like props on either side of the pulpit, seemed necessary rather
to support the person than to assist the gesticulation of the
preacher,—no gown, not even that of Geneva, a tumbled band, and a gesture which
seemed scarcely voluntary, were the first circumstances which struck a stranger.
‘The preacher seems a very ungainly person,’ whispered Mannering to his new
"‘Never fear, he is the son of an
excellent Scottish lawyer, he’ll show blood, I’ll warrant him.’
"The learned counsellor predicted
truly. A lecture was delivered, fraught with new, striking, and entertaining
views of Scripture history - a sermon in which the Calvinism of the Kirk of
Scotland was ably supported, yet made the basis of a sound system of practical
morals, which should neither shelter the sinner under the cloak of speculative
faith or of peculiarity of opinion, nor leave him loose to the waves of unbelief
and schism. Something there was of an antiquated turn of argument and metaphor,
but it only served to give zest and peculiarity to the style of elocution. The
sermon was not read—a scrap of paper, containing the heads of the discourse, was
occasionally referred to, and the enunciation, which at first seemed imperfect
and embarrassed, became, as the preacher warmed in his progress, animated and
distinct: and although the discourse could not be quoted as a correct specimen
of pulpit eloquence, yet Mannering had seldom heard so much learning,
metaphysical acuteness, and energy of argument brought into the service of
christianity. ‘Such,’ he said, going out of the church, ‘must have been the
preachers, to whose unfearing minds, and acute though sometimes rudely exercised
talents, we owe the reformation.’
"And yet that reverend
gentleman,’ said Pleydell, ‘whom I love for his father’s sake and his own, has
nothing of the sour or pharisaical pride which has been imputed to some of the
early fathers of the Calvinistic kirk of Scotland. His colleague and he differ,
and head different parties in the kirk, about particular points of church
discipline; but without for a moment losing personal regard or respect for each
other, or suffering malignity to interfere in an opposition, steady, constant,
and apparently conscientious on both sides.’"
Dr Erskine was married to
Christian Mackay, third daughter of George, third lord Ray, by whom he had a
family of fourteen children, but of whom only four survived him, David Erskine,
Esq. of Carnock, and three daughters.
The works written by Dr Erskine
1st, The Law of Nature
sufficiently promulgated to the Heathen World ; or, an Inquiry into the ability
of the Heathens to discover the being of a God, and the immortality of human
souls, in some miscellaneous reflections occasioned by Dr Campbell’s (professor
of Divinity at St Andrews) Treatise on the necessity of Revelation. Edinburgh,
1741. Republished in "Theological Dissertations." London, 1765.
2d, The Signs of the Times considered; or,
the high probability that the present appearances in New England, and the West
of Scotland, are a prelude to the glorious things premised to the Church in the
latter ages. Edinburgh, 1742. Anonymous.
3d, The People of God considered as all
righteous; or, three Sermons, preached at Glasgow, April, 1745. Edinburgh, 1745.
Republished in the first volume of Dr Erskine’s Discourses.
4th, Meditations and Letters of a Pious
Youth, lately deceased, (James Hall, Esq., son of the late Sir John Hall, Bart.
of Dunglass), to which are prefixed, Reflections on his death and character, by
a friend in the country. Edinburgh, 1746.
5th, An account of the Debate in the Synod
of Glasgow and Ayr, October 6th, 1748; respecting the employment of Mr
Whitefield to preach in the pulpits of the Synod. Edinburgh, 1748. Anonymous.
6th, An humble attempt to promote frequent
Communicating. Glasgow, 1749. Republished in "Theological Dissertations."
7th, The Qualifications necessary for
Teachers of Christianity; a Sermon before the Synod of Glasgow and Ayr, 2d
October, 1750. Glasgow, 1750. Republished in Discourses, vol. II.
8th, The Influence of Religion on National
Happiness; a sermon preached at the anniversary meeting of the Society for
Propagating Christian Knowledge, in the high Church of Edinburgh, January, 1756.
9th, Ministers of the Gospel cautioned
against giving offence; a sermon before the Synod of Lothian and Tweeddale,
November 3d, 1763; to which is added, A Charge at the Ordination of the late Mr
Robertson, minister of Ratho. Edinburgh, 1764. Republished in Discourses, vol.
10th, Mr Wesley’s Principles detected; or,
a defence of the Preface to the Edinburgh edition of "Aspasio Vindicated,"
written by Dr Erskine in answer to Mr Kershaw’s Appeal—to which is prefixed the
Preface itself. Edinburgh, 1765.
11th, Theological Dissertations, (1) On
the Nature of the Sinai covenant, (2) On the Character and Privileges of the
Apostolic churches, (3) On the Nature of Saving Faith, (1) See lst, (5) See 6th.
12th, Shall I go to War with my American
Brethren? A discourse on Judges xx. 28, addressed to all concerned in
determining that important question. London, 1769. Anonymous. Reprinted in
Edinburgh with a Preface and Appendix, and the author’s name, 1776.
13th, The Education of the poor children
recommended; a sermon before the Managers of the Orphan Hospital, 1774.
14th, Reflections on the Rise, and
Progress, and probable Consequences of the present contentions with the
Colonies: by a Freeholder. Edinburgh, 1776.
15th, The Equity and Wisdom of the
Administration, on measures that have unhappily occasioned the American Revolt -
tried by the Sacred Oracles. Edinburgh, 1776.
16th, Considerations on the Spirit of
Popery, and the intended Bill for the relief of the Papists in Scotland.
17th, A Narrative of the Debate in the
General Assemble of the Church of Scotland, May 25th, 1779. Occasioned by the
apprehensions of an intended repeal of the penal statutes against Papists. With
a dedication to Dr George Campbell, principal of the Marischal College,
Aberdeen. Edinburgh, 1780.
18th, Prayer for those in civil and
military offices, recommended from a view of the influence of Providence on
their character, conduct, and success; a sermon preached before the election of
the Magistrates of Edinburgh, October 5th, 1779, and published at the request of
the Magistrates and Town council.
19th, Sketches and Hints of Church History
and Theological Controversy, chiefly translated and abridged from modern foreign
writers, vol. 1. Edinburgh, 1790.
20th, Letters, chiefly written for
comforting those bereaved of Children and Friends. Collected from books and
manuscripts. Edinburgh, 1790. 2d edition with additions. Edinburgh, 1800.
21st, The fatal Consequences and the
General Sources of Anarchy; a discourse on Isaiah, xxiv. 1, 5; the substance of
which was preached before the Magistrates of Edinburgh, September, 1792;
published at their request, and that of the members of the Old Grey Friars Kirk
Session. Edinburgh, 1793.
22d, A Supplement to Two Volumes,
published in 1754, of Historical Collections, chiefly containing late remarkable
instances of Faith working by Love; published from the Manuscript of the late Dr
John Gillies, one of the ministers of Glasgow. With an account of the Pious
Compiler, and other additions. Edinburgh, 1796.
23d, Sketches and Hints of Church History
and Theological Controversy, chiefly translated and abridged from modern foreign
writers, vol. II. Edinburgh, 1797.
24th, Discourses preached on several
occasions, vol. I. 2d edition, 1798. Volume 11. posthumous, prepared for the
press and published by Sir H. Moncrieff Wellwood, 1804.
25th, Dr Erskine’s reply to a printed
Letter, directed to him by A. C.; in which the gross misrepresentations in said
letter, of his Sketches of Church History, in promoting the designs of the
infamous sect of the Illuminati, are considered. Edinburgh, 1798.
Those Works which were edited by Dr
Erskine, or for which he wrote prefaces are:-
lst, Aspasio Vindicated, or the Scripture
doctrine of imputed righteousness defended against the animadversions, &c. of Mr
Wesley; with a preface of ten pages by Dr Erskine. Edinburgh, 1765.
2d, An Account of the Life of the late
Rev. Mr David Brainerd, &c. by Jonathan Edwards. Edinburgh, 1765.
3d, An Essay on the continuance of
immediate Revelations of Facts and Future Events, in the Christian church, by
the Rev. Thomas Gillespie, minister of the Gospel at Dunfermline; together with
a Letter by the late Mr Cuthbert, minister of Culross, on the danger of
considering the influence of the Spirit as a rule of Duty; with a Preface by Dr
Erskine. Edinburgh, 1774.
4th, A Treatise on Temptation, by the Rev.
Thomas Gillespie. Prefaced by Dr Erskine, 1771.
5th, A History of the work of Redemption,
by the late Jonathan Edwards, 8vo. Edinburgh, 1774.
6th, Sermons on various important
subjects, by Jonathan Edwards, l2mo. Edinburgh, 1785.
7th, Dying Exercises of Mrs Deborah
Prince, and Devout Meditations of Mrs Sarah Gill, daughters of the late Rev.
Thomas Prince, minister of South church Boston, New England. 1785.
8th, Six Sermons, by the late Rev. Thomas
Prince, A. M., one of the ministers in the South Church, Boston. Published from
his manuscript, with a Preface by Dr Erskine, containing a very interesting
account of the Author, of his Son who pre-deceased him, and of three of his
9th, Practical Sermons, by the Rev. Thomas
Prince, 8vo, 1788.
10th, Twenty Sermons, by the Rev. Thomas
Prince, on various subjects. Edinburgh, 1789.
11th, A Reply to the Religious Scruples
against Innoculating the Small-pox, in a letter to a friend, by the late
Rev. William Cooper of Boston, New England. Edinburgh, 1791.
12th, The safety of appearing at the Day
of’ Judgment in the Righteousness of Christ, opened and applied, by Solomon
Stoddart, pastor to the church of Northhampton, in New England, the grandfather
and predecessor of Mr Jonathan Edwards. Edinburgh, 1792.
Fourth edition, with a Preface, containing
some account of him, and an acknowledgment of the unscripturalness of some of
13th, Miscellaneous Observations on
Important Theological Subjects, by the late Jonathan Edwards. Edinburgh, 1793.
14th, Sermons and Tracts, separately
published at Boston, Philadelphia, and now first collected into one volume, by
Jonathan Dickenson, A. M., late President of the College of New Jersey.
15th, A Sermon preached on the Fast Day,
28th February, 1794, at the French Chapel Royal, at St James’s, and at the Royal
Crown Court, Soho, by Mr Gilbert. Translated from the French by a young Lady, Dr
Erskine’s grand-daughter, lately dead (daughter of Charles Stuart, M. D.), with
a short Preface by Dr Erskine. Edinburgh, 1794,
16th Remarks on Important Theological
Controversies, by Mr Jonathan Edwards, 1796.
17th, Select Discourses, by eminent
ministers in America. 2 volumes. Edinburgh, 1796.
18th, Religious Intelligence and
seasonable Advice from Abroad, concerning lay preaching and exhortation, in four
separate Pamphlets. Edinburgh, 1801.
19th, Discourses on the Christian Temper,
by J. Evans, D. D., with an account of the Life of the author, by Dr Erskine.
20th, New Religious Intelligence, chiefly
from the American States. Edinburgh, 1802.
Account of the life and writings of
John Erskine, D.D
By Sir Henry Moncreiff-Wellwood (1818)