Search just our sites by using our customised search engine

Unique Cottages | Electric Scotland's Classified Directory

Click here to get a Printer Friendly PageSmiley

History of the Queen's Park Football Club 1867 - 1917
Chapter XII.—Three Historic Games


The name of the Vale of Leven player who scored the first goal ever taken from the Queen's Park, deserves to be handed down to posterity. It was a famous deed in the annals of football, to storm a virgin fortress, which had withstood many sieges successfully for a period of nearly eight years—namely, from 9th July, 1867, until 16th January, 1875. It was done in a great game, forcible as games go nowadays, for charging —strenuous, unlicensed, yet fair charging—was legitimate in those days. A Scottish Cup tie, too, played on Hampden Park. It is strange to read that "there was a good deal of speculation on the event in a small way, five to two being freely laid on the Queen's Park, and, as results proved, those who did so were in the right." A special train was run from Alexandria, and in the city the match was the principal topic of conversation. The crowd of 10,000—a large turnout at the time—was comprised, we are informed, of "a mixed mob of gentlemen and roughs." The latter tore up palings, and used them as vaulting poles. The Queen's Park scored first. "Herriot" (whose real identity was Highet) made a clever thrown-in, and followed up hard, centering to M'Gill,. who shot through, and secured an unmistakable goal, amidst the loud cheers of the partisans of the home team. Then came the Vale's turn. Dickson, the Queen's Park custodian, had been forced to kick off several times, and "a hand," followed by a place kick from M'Lintock, right in front of the goal, caused the home backs to crowd under their tape.. A corner kick was the result. M'Lintock placed the ball well to R. Paton, who, with his head, in a scrimmage forced it through, just as half-time was called. To R. Paton, then, belongs the honour of being the first Scot to score against the Queen's Park. Both sides were now even; but the confidence of the Queen's Park men in their ability to win the match:

was not abated. The getting of the winning goal was no mean task. Weir and M'Neil were doing great work, both being artful dodgers. We are told, Ferguson of the Vale, who showed astonishing speed, backed by M'Lintock, charged furiously at every one before him, worked the ball up the Queen's right wing, and it was sent into touch for safety. The ball came back down the field diagonally to the Vale's left corner, where H. M'Neil got a place kick for "a hand," and, passing the ball neatly to Philips, the latter passed it to Weir, who again served it to M'Neil, who sent it through. This was the winning goal. Though twenty minutes were to go, the reporter gravely states " the game was now virtually over." So it was, as no more goals were scored. "Weir, who had been getting rather severe treatment all day, was afterwards furiously charged, and had to retire lame, with his right leg badly cut." "Herriot" played with great dash and pluck, and backed up Harry M'Neil, who at the outset was "knocked out of tune by repeated charges," but latterly made some splendid runs, and showed greater pace with the ball at his foot than his fleet-footed opponent, Ferguson. M'Kinnon and M'Gill did timely work in the centre, and T. Lawrie also played determinedly, but found that his forward man, Weir, was too well watched for him to be of much service. " It is a well-known fact Weir can keep possession of the ball for a time against any single player in Scotland, but from the outset he seemed to be 'spotted' as a dangerous man, and had to stand furious charges from M'Lintock and others of the Vale men on the opposite wing." Campbell had several tries at goal, and played well throughout. Philips took his falls unconcernedly. Neill and Taylor, at back, did well ; the former never missed a kick. Dickson had more goalkeeping to do than Wood, but proved himself all there when wanted. In criticising the Vale players, the reporter is hard on M'Lintock, who showed himself a dangerous man as left half-back. "The styles of play of the two clubs were widely different. That of the Queen's Park is much the more scientific, all of their forwards relying upon their skill in dribbling, and their ability to place the ball in the best position to make use of it. A good many of the Vale men, notably one of the half-backs, seemed to devote themselves to heavy charging, more apparently with a few to temporary disablement of the object of the attack." Such was the football of the time.

Queen's Park Team—J. Dickson; J. Taylor and R. Neil ; C. Campbell and J. Philips; T. Lawrie, J. B. Weir, D. M'Gill, W. M'Kinnon, T. C. "Herriot" (Highet), and H. M'Neil.

Vale Team—W. C. Wood; W. Jameson and A. M'Intyre; J. M'Intyre and A. M'Lintock; R. Paton, J. Ferguson, M'Gregor, A. Lamont, J. Baird, and M'Dougall.

Umpires—W. G. Mitchell (Queen's Park) and J. B. Wright (Vale). Referee—Mr. Davidson (Eastern).

Once the maiden fortress was stormed by Vale of Leven, January, 1875—the fortress which Queen's Park had for so many years defended so valiantly—the secretary had to report to the annual general meeting of 1875 that four goals had been lost that season—one to Vale of Leven, two to Clydesdale in the second of the series of three games in the Scottish Cup semi-final (0-0, 2-2, 1-0), and one in the first return game against Notts at Nottingham (1-1). The first game with Clydesdale was played at Kinning Park, 20th March, 1875. The second had Hampden Park as the venue, on 27th March, and this match assumes an importance from the fact of other two goals being lost. A strong breeze interfered with fine play, so the "Herald" report goes. With one or two exceptions, the teams were unchanged. First honours were in favour of Clydesdale, Anderson scoring, kicking in beautifully from the corner. Sides being changed, the Queen's Park gained the advantage, formerly held by their opponents, of a favourable wind, and at once hemmed Clydesdale in their own territory, speedily securing a goal, well kicked by one of the M'Kinnons. (It was William who scored this goal.) Honours were thus well balanced; but the Clydesdale were soon placed again in the lead, and again by Anderson, who sent the ball through from the centre. On changing positions for the third time (ends were changed in those days after each goal), Highet succeeded in following Anderson's example, and on the time being called the match ended again in a draw. Both the goals scored against Queen's Park were obtained by Fred. Anderson, the Clydesdale cricketer and footballer. He was a member of Queen's Park from 28th

October, 1872, until 26th November, 1873, when he and W. C. Thomson resigned together. The third game went to Queen's Park by one goal to none. In regard to the final of that year, 10th April, 1875, on Hampden Park, Renton furnished the opposition, and Queen's Park won by three-goals to nothing. We read: "Many friends of the strangers (Renton) were present, a few of the more exuberant being at first disposed to lay odds on their chance. During the interval the strangers were refreshed by their admirers, without avail." The team which represented the Queen's Park in this final was : R. W. Neill; J. Taylor (captain) and J. Philips; C. Campbell and J. Dickson; T. Highet, H. M'Neil, W. M'Kinnon, A. M'Kinnon, T. Lawrie, and J. B. Weir.


The Queen's Park, after holding a record unique in football, met with what was nothing short of a calamity from the Wanderers at the Oval, London, 5th February, 1876. Up to this match no reverse had been recorded against the club, and this was the ninth season of its history—a phenomenal record truly. The Wanderers had been met twice before— 4th March, 1872, in the initial competition for the English Cup, just instituted, a draw—no goals—being the result; and again, 9th October, 1875, at Hampden Park, the Queen's Park being in the ascendant by five goals to none. The third meeting was the return to the second game. How the Association game had risen in the estimation of the public, who demanded good descriptions of the more important games, is evidenced by the column report telegraphed from London to the "North British Daily Mail" on the Sunday after the match ; full and critical in style, and sympathetic in tone, seeing the Queen's Park met its Flodden—its first defeat. Snow had fallen overnight; the ground was a quagmire. There was a bitter wind with a good deal of north in it, and only a thousand spectators—one-tenth of the number at the game at Hampden Park between the same clubs a few months before. The ground was much too narrow, and consequently the ball was ever getting out of play. Several times it was kicked on to the pavilion, and over the spectators; once the ball went clean over the pavilion. After Hampden Park, this was against the Queen's Park team doing themselves justice. Notwithstanding, the deponent states he never saw a faster, or finer game, or one more gallantly contested. If there was any advantage in the early part of the game, it lay with the Wanderers, as Dickson had to exercise his cleverness to avert hostile demonstrations against his charge. The Scots too were very busy. At the end of half an hour the Wanderers took the ball down to their opponents' end, and became entitled to a corner kick. The ball was well placed by Maddison, and, after a momentary scrimmage, pressed under the tape from Wolliston's head. There was nothing noteworthy until the call of half-time. The game up to this point had been good, spirited, and very fast indeed, but the Scots, it must be admitted, had had the worst of it, independently of the goal scored against them. The Englishmen had to work very hard to resist the untiring pertinacity of the Scots. Ends had been changed only five minutes when Heron, after a fine run, passed the ball to Wolliston, who sent it to Kendrick, and the last named kicked a second goal for the Wanderers. The play was wanting in striking individual features, but continued to be distinguished by wonderful agility and pluck on the part of the Queen's Park men, who saw all hope of repeating the victory of October depart from them. A really splendid rush by the Queen's Park was almost crowned with success. A kick at goal just failed, and the Wanderers won by two goals to none, and the Queen's Park had to lower its flag for the first time in its history. The great weakness was the partial disablement of Weir, who had twisted his knee a few weeks back, and could not play in anything like his usual brilliant style. Indeed he should not have played at all, as, invaluable as he was when well, a man with a "game" leg is out of place in a football match. Of the Queen's Park, Harry M'Neil, M'Gill, and "Herriot" were the most prominent forwards, while Campbell and Taylor distinguished themselves in the back play. It is no mere complimentary phrase to say the Scots played well enough to win nine games out of any ten. They were agile, speedy, and, of course, plucky. The crack Glasgow club is a little ahead of all other Association clubs, and were they to compete for the Football Association Challenge Cup they would be first favourites." So the chronicler avers. The reporter seems to have been more familiar with the English players than the Scots, as he does not detail the work of the latter individually, while of the former he mentions every man.

Queen's Park Team—J. Dickson ; J. Taylor (captain) and R. W. Neill; C. Campbell and J. Philips; H. M'Neil, J. B. Weir, D. M'Gill, W. M'Kinnon, T. C. "Herriot" (Highet), and M. M'Neil.

Wanderers' Team—W. D. Greig; W. S. Rawson and A. H. Stratford; P. H. Birley (captain) and F. M. Maddison; C. H. Wolliston, Herbert Heron, H. S. Otter, C. H. T. Metcalfe, Frank Heron, and J. Kendrick.

Umpires—W. C. Mitchell (Queen's Park) and C. W. Alcock (Wanderers).

Referee—R. A. Ogilvie (Clapham Rovers).


It was another wretched day, in more senses than one, when Vale of Leven, in a Scottish Cup tie, on Hampden Park, 30th December, 1876, caused the Queen's Park to lower its colours a second time in any encounter, and the first at the instance of a Scottish club. Rain fell all the time the game lasted, and the ground was a perfect quagmire. What is sauce for the goose is also equally efficacious for the male bird, were the styles of play the same. Dumbartonshire football has ever been different from the close inner dribbling and scientific passing which the Queen's Park had developed, and cultivated since its inception. It was a small but demonstrative crowd of two thousand who ventured out on this inauspicious afternoon. " Yelling, hooting, and calling out the players by cognomens were nothing compared to the coarse and vulgar pleasantries indulged in. Happily no ladies were present in the vitiated atmosphere." Rather severe criticism, but apparently it met the case. With such ground to play on, the eleven who could last longest would undoubtedly win, and the theory was well illustrated in the latter half of the game, when the Vale had the upper hand. The Queen's Park did not play nearly so well together as their opponents, and showed a decided want of that condition which had previously carried them to victory on many a hard-fought field. Against the gale and driving rain, the Vale had a bad time. Campbell had one of his headers into goal from a free kick, the spectators imagining a goal had come. Highet had another header past the left goal-post, and Wood, the Vale eleven custodian, experienced a bad time. M'Kinnon kicked clean into the goal-mouth for Wood to strike out. Now the whole team closed in on the Vale goal., Weir ended a short and brilliant run by shooting straight, but Wood got the ball away before he was charged by M'Kinnon and Highet. They protested the ball had been through. The umpires disagreed, and the referee, Mr. John Graham gave no goal. A shot from Weir, straight for goaL struck the umbrella of one of the umpires, and the chance was lost, Twice Campbell took corner kicks, which were got away by the Vale backs. Unfortunately for the Vale one of the backs "punted the ball with the wrong side of his head," and, followed by M'Kinnon and "Senior," it went through the besieged goal, amidst great excitement, and at last the efforts of the Queen's Park were rewarded, the game being twenty minutes old. After this the Queen's Park were making it hot for the Vale, and Wood got busy again. At this stage of the game the ball was useless, and a new one had to be produced. Pools of water lay on the ground, one of which is referred to as a "pond." Now the Queen's Park had to face the weather odds. Few expected they would have to play a purely defensive game. Their play lessened in vigour and dash, the energy and staying powers of the Vale actually increasing. There is a reason for everything. Eight minutes saw a wild cry of "hands" raised by the Queen's Park. Baird, Ferguson, and Lindsay rushed away. The ball came from M'Dougal to Baird, and the latter dribbled down, watching Dickson, and scored amidst the wildest excitement. The Queen's claimed a foul, and; as the umpires could not again agree, the referee voted a goal—a result which was hailed with cheers, hisses, and yelling on the part of the spectators. The report here declares Baird was one of the finest forwards that Scotland has produced. Twenty minutes later Dickson cleared a shot from Ferguson, falling on his knees in saving. Back the ball came from the foot of Baird, and after a determined scrimmage, during which the ball rolled in front of the fortress, the Queen's Park goal was stormed for the second time. The Queens Park fought very hard after this, but it was of no avail ; the Vale forwards were "as fresh as paint," and showed fine offensive play. Five minutes from time Weir, Highet, and M'Kinnon brought the ball to the verge of the Vale of Leven goal, and just as "Senior" was about to give the finishing touch, M'Intyre cleared safely. The Queen's were thus beaten by two goals to one on their own ground, in sight of their standard, which had never before been lowered in Scotland. We are gravely informed charging was indulged in to an unlimited extent, but instead of helping the success of each it rather diminished it. For the Queen's Park, M'Kinnon, Highet, and Neill played best, and at times Weir and M'Neil showed splendidly, but Weir was too well watched to do much mischief. On the Vale side, Baird, Lindsay, Ferguson, and M'Lintock completely excelled their former efforts—Baird being the best man on the field—and Wood did great work in goal. Few will grudge the Vale of Leven the proud position they had now won for themselves with their determination and pluck. It was a great achievement, but the after proceedings were peculiar, and the details form another story.

Queen's Park Team—J. Dickson ; J. Taylor (captain) and R. W. Neill; C. Campbell and J. Philips; W. M'Kinnon, A. L. "Senior," J. B. Weir, H M'Neil, T. C. Highet, and J. T. Smith.

Vale of Leven Team—W. G. Wood; A. Michie and A. M'Intyre; W. Jameson and A. M'Lintock; J. Ferguson (captain), J. Baird, J. M'Gregor, R. Paton, D. Lindsay, and J. M'Dougal.

Umpires—A. Rae (Queen's Park) and J. Wright (Vale). Referee—J. Graham (Clyde).

Return to Book Index Page


This comment system requires you to be logged in through either a Disqus account or an account you already have with Google, Twitter, Facebook or Yahoo. In the event you don't have an account with any of these companies then you can create an account with Disqus. All comments are moderated so they won't display until the moderator has approved your comment.

comments powered by Disqus