Search just our sites by using our customised search engine

Unique Cottages | Electric Scotland's Classified Directory

Click here to get a Printer Friendly PageSmiley

A Highlander and his Books

A History of Clan Campbell, Volume 2
From Flodden to the Restoration

Reviewed by: Frank R. Shaw, FSA Scot, Atlanta, GA, USA

A History of Clan Campbell, Volume 2Alastair Campbell of Airds, Unicorn Pursuivant, has done it again! Simply put, he has made my job of reviewing this book an easy one, a thing of beauty, as well as a matter of joy. Do not confuse this book with your average, run-of-the-mill clan history. If you do, you are the loser. This is a powerful book, riveting and full of "canít wait to get to the next page" writing by a master at his craft.

To know the history of Scotland is to know the history of its movers and shakers. Yet, "just to know" is not enough to get the real picture. More importantly, to understand the history of this proud nation is to be familiar with the lives of Scotlandís greatest sons - "de Brus", Wallace, Montrose, Bonnie Prince Charlie - to name just a few of the giants. But many times larger than these individual warriors are the clans they represented and brought to the battlefields of Scotland. To know the history of Scotland is to know the history of its dominant clans.

My daddy would have called them "the high and mighty". None have been higher or mightier than Clan Campbell, the clan that many love to hate. And, if you want to have a better understanding of the history of Scotland, I suggest to one and all that you buy this book, check it out of a library, or borrow it from a friend. Yes, to know the history of Scotland is to know the history of Clan Campbell because "supporting the Crown was a family tradition".

"From Flodden to the Restoration," Alastair Campbell gives us a "behind the scenes" look at "the good, the bad, and the ugly" of Clan Campbell. You will find the author candidly and refreshingly telling of the atrocities committed by the MacDonalds and the Campbells, two of Scotlandís warring clans. There is no attempt to whitewash or cover up the many incidents in history of the utter hatred these clans had for each other and the wanton destruction committed by each.

The author recounts a favorite story of mine as it pertains to the Isle of Jura where my ancestors came from. It is the story of a Shaw who offered to fight for the Macleans and was rejected in a rude manner by their chief. This prompted Shaw to move to the other side and fight with the MacDonalds. A showdown between the Macleans and the MacDonalds took place in Islay in 1598. (Yes, the Campbells and the MacDonalds fought to the death with other clans, not just each other). "Before the battle was joined, so goes the story, Lachlan Mor had been approached by Dubh-sidh or Shaw of Jura. Shaw was a small man and his offer of service was contemptuously rejected by the Maclean Chief. This did him no good at all since the insulted Shaw waited until he had his opportunity and shot Lachlan Mor with an arrow in his chest and killed him. Seeing their leader fall, the Macleans broke and ran. The survivors took refuge in the Church of Kilnave, overlooking the broad sands of the bay. But their refuge availed them nothing as the triumphant MacDonalds set fire to the church and burnt alive all those sheltering within it." I have often used this story to teach the lesson for one to be careful who you mock, ridicule, taunt, or make fun of because your actions could end up biting you in the you know what. This Shaw was a very small man, but he was big enough to shoot his bow, and the last laugh was on Lachlan Mor.

This is a book about Clan Campbell. But do not be lulled to sleep thinking it is one sided in favor of the Campbells. I believe the author has objectively pointed out the historical facts, pro and con, of the Campbells and the clans they fought against. He has adhered to the old saying that a "coin has two sides," and his book is full of such evidence.

Two appendices appear. One deals with a rather substantial collection of music associated with Clan Campbell that Scottish music lovers will find of interest. The other discusses the Clan symbolic emblems, and the one that spoke to me most was the reference to the place where the clan rallied. It will bring to the readerís mind the place where his or her individual clan met before going off to battle. Right now, I can picture in my mind Clan Shaw joining with its fellow members of Clan Chattan at the auld Dunlichity kirk, where I have stood many times taking the same pictures on each trip. They met to sharpen their weapons on the corner of the stone church where one will find today a sword-worn indentation that is centuriesí old. Some things you just never forget, and this is a book that falls in the same category! (3/9/03)

See also A Chat with Alastair Campbell of Airds

Return to April/May 2003 Index Page


This comment system requires you to be logged in through either a Disqus account or an account you already have with Google, Twitter, Facebook or Yahoo. In the event you don't have an account with any of these companies then you can create an account with Disqus. All comments are moderated so they won't display until the moderator has approved your comment.

comments powered by Disqus