Search just our sites by using our customised search engine

Unique Cottages | Electric Scotland's Classified Directory

Click here to get a Printer Friendly PageSmiley

Dr Robert D McIntyre
Chapter 2 - Edinburgh and Daniel Stewart’s

After eleven years in Motherwell, the McIntyre Family moved to Edinburgh where the Rev John McIntyre took charge of St Mary’s United Free Church. luckily with a manse in Inverleith Place.

At the age of forty-eight, John McIntyre had moved up in the world and, in other tenus. this change brought about a transformation in the family’s outlook.

So far as John, William. Robert and Anne were concerned, a major change took place in their schooling. Anne went off to Mary Erskine’s and the boys were enrolled at Daniel Stewart’s College. The enrolment numbers are found in the ledger-like volumes which the school still holds:

  • John (No 6676) admitted September 1917
  • William (No 7074) admitted September 1921

  • Robert (No 7243) admitted January 1923

Robert attended Daniel Stewart’s for seven years and, while it is difficult to gauge the exact effect on his character of this school, there can be little doubt of its influence. It must have been exceedingly strange to go from Motherwell and Hamilton to the imposing structure of the Edinburgh school founded as a hospital by Daniel Stewart, a Perthshire lad, who came to the city as a "wig maker’s" apprentice in the mid-l8th century and, by dint of luck and effort, succeeded in acquiring resources sufficient, on his death in 1814, to sçt up a Trust with the principle aim of establishing a hospital for boys.

What we see today in the exterior of the present main building differs little from the hospital which was opened in 1855. Ironically, perhaps, the Trustee chose a building designed by the architect, David Rind, derived from plans which came second when submitted in the competition for the new Houses of Parliament.

In the 1920’s. Daniel Stewart’s had over 600 pupils presided over by Dr C H Milne, who had been appointed in 1911 and who, by all accounts, was an aloof and austere domini who had little rapport with the boys, and ii is surprising that his reign lasted until 1935.

Stewart’s, as a fee paying school, could be highly selective. While accepting this element, Robert insists that, while it was fee paying, "it was not a snob school".

Again the fees for four children must have been a strain on a Minister’s stipend (Anne having joined Mary Erskine’s,) which was only partly relieved by the brilliance of at least one of the family, William being able to obtain a remission of fees by being an extremely able scholar.

Robert admits that he was a "lazy" student, but able, and, to some extent, this is borne out by his failure to get the "Highers" grouping to enable him to fulfil his ambition to do pure science at University.

While the overall influence of the school on Robert and his brothers is hard to assess, at least one master made a lasting impression on him, Dr John Oliver who taught English and History - and much more. McIntyre tells a story of a lesson on ‘justice", which had little to do with the formal topics of the school room.

Apparently. one boy had misbehaved and was about to be punished in the fashion of the time. All knew that he had committed the alleged offence but the pupil contested the imminent punishment. So there took place a dialogue of questions and answers between pupil and master - unusual for the 1920’s. At the end, the master concluded, "All right. Away you go." and put the tawse back into the desk.

Dr Oliver must have made an impact on many more pupils than Robert. His character inspired the verse:

Beneath your curly pow, John
Where is there room to stow
Such learning, wit and kindliness
John Olive, my Jo

Not up to Burns, but indicative of the affection and respect which teachers can arouse in pupils whom they might be forgiven in thinking are not responsive in any shape or form.

What seems quite odd, in such a close-knit family of the manse living in Edinburgh, is that the boys seemed content to "gang their am gait". Some of this may be explained by age differences, but there is little evidence that many of their extra-curricular interests were shared.

Robert might have been a lazy pupil but he showed great energy in a range of out with school activities. At this stage of growing up, he developed a remarkable affection for the sea and boats, part of which must have come from his father who, at this time (1928), writes of his own boyhood experiences of boating on the Firth of Clyde in an introductory passage in his book, "The Idealism of Jesus". In this, he states, "The tide is rising. Where is the Church? Is she ready and waiting for the tide, or high and dry on some lonely beach, oblivious that the night is coming again and a weary wester must cut her off from the homeward breeze".

But his son’s seaward urges were more experimental. Robert’s ventures into naval architecture were adventurous to the point of being foolhardy.

A group of school friends had a joint venture in a "whaler" which was about 20ft in length - purchased for the princely sum of about £2.10s. They repaired and painted it and were able to make it sufficiently riverworthy to sail on the Forth.

Robert got hold of the plans for a canoe from the Boy’s Own paper and set about its construction in the loft of the house. His ingenuity in this deserves great praise. He obtained the canvas from an Elder of the Kirk who happened to work in the Post Office and who had access to the old mail bags that the Post Office discarded. The completed vessel was adequate enough to be paddled on the Forth and to take the Builder’s Mother and Father aboard, which shows their faith in their son’s ability as well as in the Lord’s.

Later, during a holiday in Granton-on-Spey, he made what can only be described as a coracle using materials growing near the river, like alder. This craft was able to give the maker a break from exam swatting by affording trips on Loch Garten. Sadly, it came to grief under the bridge on the Spey at Nethybridge where spikes of wood fouled the boat and punctured the Post Office canvass. However, nothing daunted, the designer took the view that the experiment had been a success, in that his construction had worked to his satisfaction and had given him a great deal of pleasure.

While the idea of going off to sea did cross his mind, his immediate goal was to achieve the necessary qualifications which would enable him to enter university.

Previous | Index Page | Next


This comment system requires you to be logged in through either a Disqus account or an account you already have with Google, Twitter, Facebook or Yahoo. In the event you don't have an account with any of these companies then you can create an account with Disqus. All comments are moderated so they won't display until the moderator has approved your comment.

comments powered by Disqus