Search just our sites by using our customised search engine
Unique Cottages | Electric Scotland's Classified Directory

Click here to get a Printer Friendly PageSmiley

Dr Robert D McIntyre
Chapter 4 - Edinburgh and its University

But what of Edinburgh itself? Scots have held contradictory views of their capital and its people. The oft quoted, "East Windy, West Endy" is too glib, but does as a sound bite.

MacDiarmid’s more expansionist opinions of the capital in the 1930’s exhibit a love/hate relationship. He quotes a young Scottish writer as saying, "Edinburgh, the Edinburgh of our time, is a capital city, with a provincial population, a Scottish city whose people strive to be English and succeed in being nothing in particular." The young writer suggests that Edinburgh’s inhospitable clime forces "young men of promise to flee to London and Paris, these genuine capitals, where it is possible to be superior without being so terribly in earnest about it".

MacDiarmid’s concurrence with these views is limited because he has "no faith in those young men who fall to London and Paris", and he concludes "If one is to live in Scotland, it is necessary to live in Edinburgh. There is no place else".

After a short period in an Accountants’ office, Robert managed to acquire the necessary qualifications to enter Edinburgh University and proceeded, initially, to study pure science and, after about a year, he switched to medicine.

And in this complex political and social atmosphere, he began the task of developing his own political views and opinions. Additionally, and, as important, he fashioned a form of personal organisation and management which was to characterise his behaviour from then on.

He built up an ability to combine a use and an apportioning of his time to obtain the maximum effect on a particular sphere of interest, and yet appear to be unhurried and have some time left over for "leisure" - rather like the good footballer who operates in the crowded penalty box to great effect to notch up the goals, but makes it look easy by appearing to have more time than actually is available.

Robert’s day could commence with a botany lecture at 8am and go on until 5pm at the University and, of course, further study was required after the formal lectures. When asked how he fitted in his other activities without exhausting himself his modest reply is, "Ah well, I seemed to have managed", and that reply is an attempt to conceal his considerable ability to put more into each day than seems possible.

University politics captured his attention and he became Chairman of the University Labour Party. His political views at this time are distinctly left of centre. He did not object to being called a socialist, but he resisted the attempts to change the name of the University Labour Party to the Socialist Society.

But, as would be expected in student politics, Robert was not confined to the mundane. He got involved in an attempt to have Leon Trotsky stand as Rectorial candidate for the University and wrote a letter to Trotsky who was on the run from Stalin, only to find it well near impossible to make contact with the Russian revolutionary. Apparently, the problem was solved by making an approach to a local member of the British Section of the International Socialist Labour Party in Edinburgh who undertook to have McIntyre’s letter delivered. Unfortunately, Trotsky turned down what was an all-party invitation on the basis of desiring to stand on his "own ticket". During this period of University political activity, Robert’s disenchantment with the Labour Party took hold. The University Labour Party had sent a resolution to the Scottish Council of the Labour Party for debate at the Annual Conference, which at this time could not discuss policy. This posture, not unnaturally, horrified the Chairman of the University Labour Club.

However, his political activities were not confined to the University precincts. The Annual Report of the Edinburgh Trades and Labour Council for 1935 records RD McIntyre was the delegate from the University Labour Party, succeeding his brother, J E McIntyre, who had held this position in the year previous.

At this time, the Trades and Labour Council had a wide remit and brought together not only Trades Unions but a range of local political organisations and left-wing societies, including the Fabians and the Co-operative Party. Robert certainly gained a considerable knowledge in a short time of different approaches to political organisation and the vagaries of political outlook and action. He recalls being put at the head of a fund-raising activity during the Civil War in Spain. He was aware that, coming from the Medical School in the University this would give the organisation a degree of "respectability", but he was not so naive as to fall for the proposals emanating from the Communist adherents on the committee to have the funds raised by public appeal sent to a "front" organisation in Paris. Robert did not fall for these tricks and the funds went to support the Republicans in Spain, as was intended.

He moved outside the cloistered atmosphere of the University debates to practise skills in public speaking and, on occasions, found himself using the forum at the Mound. This somewhat surprised his brother, William, when he first encountered his "wee brother" laying forth. Nevertheless, his verdict was not ungenerous in that he thought that Robert "was more than holding his own."

Previous | Index Page | Next


This comment system requires you to be logged in through either a Disqus account or an account you already have with Google, Twitter, Facebook or Yahoo. In the event you don't have an account with any of these companies then you can create an account with Disqus. All comments are moderated so they won't display until the moderator has approved your comment.

comments powered by Disqus