Scottish Fiddlers - 25th in
Series, “The Scotia Sun” May 9, 1973
Scottish music, in the
finest Cape Breton tradition, lives on in Detroit, Michigan, thanks to
Johnny Archie MacDonald who grew up in Little Judique Ponds just after the
turn of the century.
Johnny Archie is almost
eighty years old now and in the half century since he left Cape Breton he
has nursed Scottish music through a long succession of music crazes
enabling it to survive in the Motor City.
With the aid of other
former Cape Bretoners Johnny Archie has sponsored dances, organized
concerts and opened his home to musicians. Now, he has resigned himself
to entertaining family and friends in his home where he still loved to
play his Roth violin.
A retired Detroit police
Officer, Johnny Archie was born on May 22, 1893 in Superior, Wisconsin.
At age seven, after the death of his mother, Johnny Archie and his
father moved to Little Judique Ponds, where he resided until moving to
Moncton, New Brunswick in 1921 with his new bride, the former Florence
MacKillop of Judique. They moved to Detroit, Michigan in 1924.
Florence and J.A. had eight
children. Tragedy struck the family twice in 1938 when a daughter
Christine, died followed by the death of Florence. In 1946, J.A. married
Dorothy Hogan of Boston, Massachusetts. They had five children before
Dorothy died in 1957.
J.A. comes from a musical
family. His grandfather, Donald Macdonald was the only fiddler in Little
Judique in his day, so he played at all the weddings and dances in the
area. Sometimes he was so busy playing that he had to drink his whiskey
while playing. Four of his sons learned to play the violin, including
J.A.'s father. He went on to explain, “I also inherited music from my
mother, the former Florence Beaton from Little Judique. People have told
me that both she and her brother, the late John Archie Beaton were noted
step dancers and Gaelic and English singers.
As a boy, J.A. would use
two kindling wood sticks as an imaginary violin and bow and pretend he was
playing. When his father left home to seek work in California and Alaska,
he left behind an old violin which J.A. picked at until he learned to play
“The Cock of the North” when he was 17.
There weren't many fiddlers
around Judique then. One would have to go to Mabou and further north to
hear the good fiddlers. The late Big John Alex MacDonald and the late
Alex Michael MacDonald moved to Port Hood some time later, and J.A.
recalls that they were two musicians whom he admired and learned from.
Reminiscing recently in his
Detroit home, J.A. said, “I never learned to read music, which I deeply
regret to this day. However, I did have a good ear for music in my
younger days. I could pick a tune by hearing it just once.. I do know
that no one can play by ear like those who can read music.'
Fondly recalling childhood
experiences, J.A. said, “Years ago in Cape Breton, the big day was July
1st and there would be picnic in Inverness Town and all the top violin
players and piano players would gather there. I always made it a point to
attend that picnic. I dearly loved to dance, but on that day, I parked
myself right behind the fiddler's stage and there I stayed all day.
“I remember at one
particular July 1st picnic I learned 13 tunes and in a few days I played
them all at home,” he said. “It was at one of those picnic that I first
head a young girl, who is now Mrs. Hugh MacDonald from Mabou and New
Waterford. She and her sister played together. I was spellbound and
certain I was in another world listening to that music. I have since
heard Mary playing many times, and to me, Mary Beaton Macdonald is in a
class of her own.”
Johnny Archie often
practiced on the violin at home, unknown to anyone, except his stepmother,
who liked to tease him by saying in Gaelic “I thought it was Donald John
the Tailor I heard playing”.. Donald John has been called the Strathspeys
J.A. first played publicly
at a dance in Judique schoolhouse when Allan MacDonnell, the lone violin
player at the dance, offered his instrument to J.A. in return for a dance
with his girl friend. Without saying a word, J.A. started playing.
“Allan and my girlfriend stood there definitely surprised, never dreaming
that I would actually take him up on it,” he recalled. “I played three
sets that night, and after that, at any dance I attended, I had to take my
In the absence of
recreation in Little Judique Ponds, the young folks liked to gather in the
evening at the Maryville railroad station, a way station where mailbags
were dropped. One night J.A. perched himself on a lobster crate in an
empty boxcar and played his violin until well after midnight while his
friends square danced. On another occasion, J.A. and his friends utilized
his boat for an impromptu dance. “I was running a lobster smack and I had
a large boat” he said. “One Sunday my friends asked me to take them for
a sail around the Port Hood Islands, so we took off for the outer
islands. There was a good floor in the boat and we had a fiddle so I
started to play. The girls and boys got on the boat floor and danced
three sets while we circled both islands.”
“In 1923 I played a few
square dances with a very fine violin player at a garden party in Mabou.
This man was Angus R. Beaton (Blacksmith), father of Donald Angus Beaton.
I was thrilled at playing with such a good player and after we finished,
Mr. Beaton asked me just who I was and where I hailed from. I replied
that I came from Little Judique Ponds. Mr. Beaton recalled that some
years back there was a man by the name of Hugh MacDonald who worked in one
of the general stores in Mabou. This man was also a fine violin player
and he and Mr. Beaton became good friends and played at many dances and
weddings together. This Hugh MacDonald was my uncle. In 1939, at the age
of 86, my uncle Hugh visited my home in Detroit and even then was able to
play the old tunes very well. He too recalled Angus R. Beaton and told me
of what a fine violin player Beaton was.”
Johnny Archie's fifty-odd
years in Detroit include just as many cherished memories as his Judique
days and every one of them is related to Scottish music, naturally. His
down east dances, which featured such Cape Bretoners as Angus Chisholm,
Cameron Chisholm, John Campbell, Donald Campbell, Winston Fitzgerald,
Donald MacLellan and Buddy MacMaster, have thrilled Detroiters on many a
Besides dances, J.A. has
usually always had a hand in organizing Scolong dream, he played the
pipes for his father. He has been studying only a short time - but
according to J.A. (and again he says he is prejudiced) “Charlie plays
quite well, he has good time and plays the types correct. Since he did
start to play later in life, his best asset is certainly that the music
is in him.” Charlie's daughter Sandy is a highland dancer and has won
many medals and awards for her dancing in different competitions
throughout the West. Of course, J.A. is quite proud of his offspring
(12 children, 25 grandchildren and 8 great-grandchildren) are so fond of
music. He feels that music makes life much fuller and more enriched.
(Besides, how many other families have their own 'Lawrence Welk Program”
when they get together?). As he so aptly put it, 'I love our Scottish
music even more than the corned hake that is shipped to me every fall
from Leslie Toby from Port Hood Island”.
Johnny Archie's violin is
a Roth which he bought from the late Danny MacDonnell, a former Cape
Bretoner who lived in Detroit. “It is a very fine violin. The fiddle
was in a freak accident when it fell on the ground and was driven over
by a car, however, it was repaired by our local filled maker, Cleon
Keply, who maintained that the fiddle (which was in a box in a million
pieces) was too fine an instrument to throw away. The fiddle is now as
good as new.
On the subject of
composing Johnny Archie says “Although I did compose a few strathspeys,
reels jigs etc., through the years, since I couldn't read or write
music, I would eventually forget them. However, when the tape recorder
came into vogue, I would record them for my own use.”
J.A. is still quite
active, and makes an annual trip to Cape Breton around July 1st and
resides there for the summer in Little Judique Ponds. He has obtained
many recordings of the musicians down east, as well as Toronto and
Boston, and Detroit. One of his greatest pleasures is to sit and enjoy
every note of every tune. He still frequents the summer concerts in
Cape Breton and likes nothing better than to sit and talk “old times”
with the performers there. It is the consensus of many that Johnny
Archie is a “legend in his time” - always promoting festivities to keep
Scottish music in the hearts of people everywhere - so that Cape Breton
tradition will live on.
This comment system requires
you to be logged in through either a Disqus account or an
account you already have with Google, Twitter, Facebook or
Yahoo. In the event you don't have an account with any of these
companies then you can create an account with Disqus. All
comments are moderated so they won't display until the moderator
has approved your comment.